Did You Agree With the 2017 Oscar Winners?

In Movie Reviews, Posts, Renard Bansale, Reviews by John LaCrosse

What did you think of the Oscar winners? Would you have voted differently?
JPCatholic Film Critic Renard Bansale gives his picks below:

Written Saturday, February 25th, 2017
If Renard Voted for the 89th Academy Awards (2016)

The Oscars are this Sunday and debates and betting contests continue up until that beat of silence while the presenter opens the sealed envelope about who will win and who should win. While I do dabble in such contests, I prefer to simply stick by my personal picks (strictly from the final list of nominees), accept the presumed frontrunners, and avoid having any of the votes I had made in small contests compromise the excitement of the whole ceremony.


Best Original Song:

“City of Stars” – La La Land 
(music by Justin Hurwitz; lyrics by Benj Pasek & Justin Paul)


For every time I am tempted to vote for “Audition (The Fools Who Dream)”, which is Mia’s (Emma Stone) showstopping moment, the opening notes of arguably the film’s signature song start to play in my head. “City of Stars,” save for perhaps the opening number “Another Day of Sun” (which was not submitted to the Academy), will go down as the theme song for any artistic dreamers pondering over their chances at success and happiness.

Best Original Score:

Mica Levi – Jackie

Best Original Score Mica Levi Jackie

Justin Hurwitz will win this Oscar, but I would still vote for the score that not only stands more on its own, but continues to send chills down my spine.

Best Sound Editing:

Sylvain Bellemare – Arrival 

While the sound editing team of Hacksaw Ridge will likely claim this statuette in the end, I prefer to honor the team that had to compose the guttural yet textured audio of the Heptapod language.

Best Sound Mixing:

Ai-Ling Lee, Steve A. Morrow, & Andy Nelson – La La Land 

best sound mixing lala land

The re-recording mixers of La La Land should and will win this Oscar, which will be the third for mixing team member Andy Nelson (Saving Private Ryan, Les Miserables).

Best Visual Effects:

Steve Emerson, Oliver Jones, Brian McLean, & Brad Schiff – Kubo & the Two Strings

kubo and the two strings

I can criticize Kubo’s screenwriting all I want, but there is no denying the meticulous and time-consuming stop-motion animation craft that went into this Japanese-inspired action-adventure (especially since I disapprove of the CGI resurrection/de-aging of actors in my original choice, Rogue One: A Star Wars Story).

Best Film Editing:

Tom Cross – La La Land 

lala land best editing

Tom Cross will and should win his second editing Oscar for his equally-crisp and equally-restrained (more on that below) cutting of this joyous and lively musical.

Best Makeup & Hairstyling:

Richard Alonzo & Joel Harlow – Star Trek Beyond

star trek beyond

While I did not find the third installment in the rebooted Star Trek film franchise as worthwhile and lasting as the first and especially the second films, I will not deny that—of this peculiar batch of nominees—its makeup and prosthetic efforts deserve this Oscar the most.

Best Costume Design:

Madeline Fontaine – Jackie 

Aside from all the dashing, ’60s-era, formal attire of the politicians closest to the late president, Ms. Fontaine recreates one of fashion’s most iconic and infamous dresses in the strawberry pink Chanel suit and matching pillbox hat that Jackie Kennedy was wearing at the time of her late husband’s assassination. Most winners of this category are either Best Picture contenders or stuffy period pieces, so while I prefer that Jackie go down in cinema history as more than the latter, I am content that that description will at least earn it one statuette come Sunday evening.

Best Production Design:

 David Wasco, production design; Sandy Reynolds-Wasco, set decoration – La La Land

lala land best production

I almost considered the production design of Hail, Caesar! for a moment, but then I wondered, “Why award the recreation of the Golden Age of Hollywood just starting on its descent when I can award its emulation in enhancing real-life locations as well as elaborate fantasy sets?” You will be reminded of the power of proper framing and precise lighting whenever you watch Emma Stone grumbling over the absence of her towed car or Emma and Ryan tap-dancing before a gorgeous, magic-hour view of the valley.

Best Cinematography:

Linus Sandgren – La La Land 


I was so close to voting for Bradford Young (i.e. the first d.p. of African descent with a Cinematography Oscar nomination) for his narrow focus-heavy close and foreboding wide camerawork in Arrival. Every instance I consider doing so, however, the opening “Another Day of Sun” sequence, the whip pans of the “Summer” montage, and any other long-take sequence I have yet to mention replay in my head. (Kudos to editor Tom Cross for his restraint during such moments.)

Best Director:

Damine Chazelle – La La Land

Damine Chazelle – La La Land

Mr. Chazelle’s effort stood out the proudest among any directorial effort of 2016. His vision carried with it that irresistible magic characteristic of the best passion projects of cinema. Part of me wants to say that Mr. Chazelle’s film was to the classic Hollywood musical what Robert Zemeckis’ Who Framed Roger Rabbit was to western animation—in other words, a dream and a miracle come true.

Best Adapted Screenplay:

Barry Jenkins & Tarell Alvin McCraney (from the unpublished stage play In Moonlight, Black Boys look Blue by Tarell Alvin McCraney) – Moonlight


The triptych structure of this deeply personal character study of a sexually-confused African American male in Miami stands out as the boldest among the five adapted scripts, which will earn it the Oscar.

Best Original Screenplay:

Taylor Sheridan – Hell or High Water 

Taylor Sheridan—Hell or High Water

While many actors appreciate the tough honesty of Kenneth Lonergan’s script for Manchester by the Sea, I prefer that Best Original Screenplay goes to Taylor Sheridan’s almost-meditative exploration of generational strife via a seemingly-standard rangers-versus-bank-robbers crime thriller set in west Texas. (The fact that Mr. Sheridan also wrote the original script for 2015’s Sicario—my favorite film of 2015—also helps in my decision.)

Best Supporting Actress:

Viola Davis as “Rose Maxon” – Fences

Viola Davis as “Rose Maxon” Fences

Naomie Harris’ fiery Moonlight performance and how she gave that performance in only three days did almost sway me, but even she comes short of reaching the dramatic heights of Viola Davis, who translates her Tony Award-winning Broadway performance into an equal powerhouse of a screen performance.

Best Supporting Actor:

Dev Patel as “Saroo Brierley” – Lion

lion dev patel

Whoa, I was not expecting this. As great as Mahershala Ali was in Moonlight, I feel uncomfortable with voting for his short and subtle screen performance. Comparatively, Mr. Patel gives a borderline lead performance in Lion, but the structure of Lion justifies his supporting nomination. The emotional space given to him allows him to become an incredible presence on screen, nailing down the obsession of an adoptee discovering his distant origins.

Best Actress:

Natalie Portman as “Jacqueline ‘Jackie’ Kennedy” – Jackie

This is no stunt performance—I sincerely believed that Ms. Portman was Jackie Kennedy for the entire duration of this unorthodox biopic. She nailed the accent, she nailed the dread, the dazed sorry, the haunting paranoia, and the regret of a dream unfulfilled. She was a living ghost in this film.

Best Actor:

Denzel Washington as “Troy Maxson” – Fences 

fences denzel washington

I admired Casey Affleck’s dramatic implosion in Manchester by the Sea, but it was never the type of performance which I would immediately vote for the Oscar. At the same time, the lead male performances of 2016 were disappointing enough that I settled with Affleck. And then I watched Denzel reprising his Tony Award-winning Broadway performance while also directing himself and the cast. The electric nature of his turn felt very much like Marlon Brando in A Streetcar Named Desire—it just blows you away.

Best Documentary Short Film:

“The White Hemets” – Gran Media and Violet Films

The White Hemets Gran Media and Violet Films

The timeliness of the Syrian civil war and the availability of the short on Netflix should earn this short enough votes to claim this statuette.

Best Animated Short Film:

“Piper” – dir. Alan Barillaro; pr. Marc Sondheimer

Piper Alan Barillaro Marc Sondheimer

Of the five nominees, this Pixar short (which preceded Finding Dory in theaters) has the perfect samplings of a breezy story, a relatable conflict, and a satisfying payoff. Moreover, there is that photorealistic animation. This should give Pixar its first animated short Oscar since “For the Birds” won at the 74th ceremony (for honoring 2001 films).

Best Live Action Short Film:

“Sing” – dir. Kristof Deak

Sing Kristof Deak

Most years, this category is impossible to predict, although the Academy does have their favorites—typically cute and unchallenging over dour and thought-provoking, for example (which contrasts with animated short never going for Pixar and documentary short going for the most timely and/or “virtue-signaling” subject matter). I liked “Sing” the most, even with its somewhat difficult message surrounding a satisfying resolution. The “cute” inclinations favor “Sing” and “La Femme et le TGV”, while the political contexts of “Ennemis Interieurs” (a powerful short) and “Silent Nights” could favor them. That leaves “Timecode”, which was slight but hits the cute and fun notes while avoiding any controversial subject matter. All we can do is wait and see what the Academy chooses.

Best Documentary Feature Film:

O.J.: Made in America – dir. Ezra Edelman; pr. Ezra Edelman & Caroline Waterlow

Ezra Edelman Made in america

A colossal achievement. Yes, it is a technically more of an ESPN miniseries that premiered at Sundance and Tribeca, but I am glad the Academy probably will not care about that asterisk.

Best Animated Feature Film:

Zootopia – dir. Byron Howard & Rich Moore; pr. Clark Spencer

zootopia best animated feature film

All of the Best Animated Feature categories in this awards season have been the greatest source of anxiety for me. Yes, Zootopia has almost swept all of the necessary awards that would guarantee a win in this category, but the race is not over until it is over.

Best Foreign Language Film:

Toni Erdmann – dir. Maren Ade (Germany)

Toni Erdmann Maren Ade (Germany)

Until I saw writer-director Maren Ade’s father-daughter dramedy, the only nominee I had seen was the Swedish entry A Man Called Ove, which I enjoyed. Ms. Ade’s film and its sprawling 3-hour runtime, on the other hand, is a full-bodied tale of parental embarrassment, the negative effects of modern society, and the pressures of conformity. Yes, both young and mature viewers should be aware of two strong scenes of sex and nudity, but the rest of the film riveted me in unexpected ways—for one thing, I will never listen to Whitney Houston’s version of “Greatest Love of All” the same way again.

Best Picture:

La La Land – pr. Fred Berger, Jordon Horowitz, & Marc Platt

best picture lala land

La La Land was my favorite film of 2016, so naturally it is my pick for Best Picture. As I said in my Top 10 Films of 2016 article, “This film, to put it simply, is nothing short of an artistic miracle.” Those words still ring true for me as the time for the Oscars ceremony arrives.


  • La La Land: 7 votes [out of 14 nominations] (Picture, Director, Cinematography, Production Design, Film Editing, Sound Mixing, and Song)
  • Jackie: 3 votes [out of 3 nominationsa clean sweep!] (Actress, Costume Design, and Score)
  • Fences: 2 votes [out of 4 nominations] (Actor and Supporting Actress)
  • The remaining works come away with 1 vote each (in alphabetical order by film): Arrival (Sound Editing), Hell or High Water (Original Screenplay), Kubo & the Two Strings (Visual Effects), Lion (Supporting Actor), Moonlight (Adapted Screenplay), O.J.: Made in America (Documentary Feature Film), “Piper” (Animated Short Film), “Sing” (Live Action Short Film), Star Trek Beyond (Makeup & Hairstyling), Toni Erdmann (Foreign Language Film), “The White Helmets” (Documentary—Short Subject), and Zootopia (Animated Feature Film)
What would you vote for if you had a ballot for the 89th Academy Awards? 


About the author
Renard N. Bansale once aspired to become an astronaut, before he found his passion in film discussion, criticism, conducting script-reading sessions of feature-film screenplays, and annual Oscar tracking. Hailing from Seattle, WA, Renard is currently pursuing his M.A. in Biblical Theology (Catechetical track) at JP Catholic after graduating from the school in 2016 with a B.S. in Communications Media (Emphasis in Screenwriting).